Tessa Lark
MOZART 5
She led the orchestra with authority, a musician most
effortlessly natural.
Her first movement Adagio was slightly overplayed but the
rest of her first movement was hale, healthy and spot-on, if not the freest and
most openly expressive we have heard her play. She impressed by her
irreproachable cleanliness and confidence. Her original cadenza was charming
and brief. Her second movement was lyrical, vocal, a beautiful esquisse not
quite exquisite. Her Rondo was very good, a slightly restrained performance
with moments of gleam that this listener suspects she is holding in check in
light of the present situation.
JinJoo Cho
MOZART 5
JinJoo Cho’s sound is sweet, but not as delicate as her
intentions. Once the Allegro started, she accented every quarter with the same
emphasis, perhaps to hide her discomfort with this movement, though she marshaled
and shone in the recap. Although her intonation suffered occasionally, there
were not too many mishaps, and a small memory slip was handled with grace.
In the slow movement, the audience should have been awarded
chocolates for their patience – it was clean, steely, phrased by the bar, and
seemed endless.
Her cadenza was adequate. The Rondo was tedious and
repetitive.
Ji Yoon Lee
MOZART 5
Ms. Lee’s strength in this performance was her last movement
Rondo – which was energetic, compelling, fresh and fun. Her playing improved
with each movement and every return of the Rondo theme.
Her first movement was not inaccurate, although she seems
unwilling to sustain long notes. She has a heaving quality on such which also occasionally
impeded her slow movement, which did not drag. Her first movement Joachim cadenza was not
terribly interesting, and her second movement was one appreciatedly abridged.
~ CrackCritic
I thought Lark's 2nd movement was... in fact...exquisite. Her rapport with the ECCO was quite exhilarating. She let's the music dance. Jinjoo ' s Mozart disappointed overall. Agree with most of your points. Ji Yoon seemed to finally relax in 3rd movement. Enjoying reading your commentaries.
ReplyDeleteRackon